Andrew Gross: Watching Islanders' Matthew Schaefer play is a treat for NHL fans

Islanders defenseman Matthew Schaefer skates against the Columbus Blue Jackets in the second period of a game at UBS Arena on Tuesday. Credit: Kathleen Malone-Van Dyke
WINNIPEG, Manitoba — The most common question at Canada Life Centre before the Islanders opened a two-game road trip against the Jets on Thursday night?
What’s the kid going to do next?
Watching Matthew Schaefer play hockey — in itself a treat — carries this giddy anticipation that, in any given game, there’s the chance to see the 19-year-old do something truly special.
That’s great for the Islanders and for Schaefer. But, most importantly, it’s great for NHL fans in these road arenas Schaefer comes to only once or twice a season.
Schaefer notched his first career hat trick in Tuesday night’s 5-1 win over the Blue Jackets at UBS Arena. The three-goal outing was a first for an Islanders defenseman since Hall of Famer Denis Potvin did so in 1982 and the first for a teenaged defenseman since Hall of Famer Phil Housley’s hat trick in 1983.
What made it so memorable was Schaefer’s unabashed joy in celebrating the third goal by thrusting his arms into the air. And what made it endearing was acting his age and taking teammate Tony DeAngelo’s dubious suggestion he hop onto the ice for a quick victory lap.
Schaefer entered Thursday’s match leading the Islanders with 24 points and 15 assists and tied with captain Bo Horvat with a team-leading nine goals.
So the Winnipeg media asked Schaefer following the morning skate what he could do for an encore while suggesting he had turned the cliched sophomore slump into a “sophomore jump” for his career.
“It was a big win,” Schaefer said of Tuesday’s heroics. “My teammates are awesome. I can’t thank them enough for everything they’ve done. You know, it’s not easy coming [into the league] as a young guy, moving away from home in general. Coming in as kind of the new guy and also the young guy, to have so many guys in my corner, it’s been awesome.”
His response to the “sophomore jump,” declaration: “That’s too nice of you. You just want to keep winning, keep doing good with this team.”
Schaefer went on to outline how much he learned his first season playing all 82 games and being voted the unanimous winner of the Calder Trophy as the rookie of the year. Teammate Mathew Barzal said after Tuesday’s match that the Islanders were “watching greatness.”
Newsday asked top-line right wing Kyle Palmieri if he wonders what Schaefer might do next and the Smithtown product replied, “Maybe not on the ice,” perhaps an allusion to Schaefer’s youth.
“When you look at how he carries himself, the excitement and passion he plays with, you just know he’s going to bring it,” Palmieri said. “That’s why he’s elevated himself to a leader on this team. He’s not going to score a hat trick every night. But just the way he plays and the speed he plays the game at is great for our group.”
Islanders coach Pete DeBoer was asked the same question.
“Well, he’s that special,” DeBoer said. “It’s not lost on me, it’s my 19th year in the league, you know how fortunate and what a privilege it is to be able to work with a generational talent like that. He’s that good. I don’t take that for granted. I’ve got a front row seat every night.”
We all do, maybe not at ice level like DeBoer, but we’re all privileged to get in on the ground floor and watch Schaefer as he develops on a trajectory that suggests he’ll soon be one of the NHL’s top three to five players.
Logan Stanley, signed three days before the Islanders’ season opener on Sept. 30, has gotten a good look too as Schaefer’s primary defense partner through the first quarter of this season.
“Just trying to keep up sometimes,” the 6-7, 231-pound Stanley said. “Great skater, great kid. Defensively, he’s just as good as he is offensively, which is probably the most impressive thing at such a young age.”
Stanley missed his second game with a lower-body issue, spoiling his return to Winnipeg, where he spent his first six NHL seasons with the Jets before a late-season trade to the Sabres last season.
“Disappointed I can’t play,” Stanley said. “I’ve been looking forward to coming back since the day I signed. I’m close and feel pretty good but it would have been a little bit selfish of me to try and force it.”
Instead, Stanley was relegated to the press box, where he, along with the rest of us, could wonder what the kid would do next.
