Matthew Schaefer scores first career hat trick in Islanders' win over Blue Jackets

Islanders' Matthew Schaefer gestures to fans after scoring his first career hat trick during the third period of an NHL hockey game against the Columbus Blue Jackets on Tuesday, Nov. 17, 2026, at UBS Arena. Credit: AP/Frank Franklin II
Matthew Schaefer lofted the puck into the empty net and raised his arms in celebration.
As hats came flying out of the stands, he acknowledged the cheers and chants by skating back onto the ice after his first career hat trick.
He’s still 19. It almost certainly won’t be his last. He became just the second teenaged defenseman after Hall of Famer Phil Housley to reach 30 career goals. He now has 32 goals, matching Hall of Famer Bryan Trottier for the Islanders’ franchise lead among all teenaged skaters.
Schaefer’s pursuit of his first career three-goal game put plenty of excitement into an otherwise non-descript match as the Islanders earned their first three-game winning streak of the season with a 5-1 win over the Eastern Conference-worst Blue Jackets on Tuesday night at UBS Arena. It was their lone home match in a six-game stretch.
Importantly, all three wins have come in regulation for the Islanders (10-6-4).
The performance was far from the Islanders’ best despite the one-sided score but beating the Blue Jackets (7-12-0), who have been outscored 21-8 in a five-game losing streak, didn’t take their A Game. Both teams turned the puck over but the Islanders mostly kept the Blue Jackets’ shots to the outside and limited traffic at the net for rebounds.
Ilya Sorokin made 28 saves and improved to 9-0-3 in his career against the Blue Jackets. Counterpart Cam Talbot stopped 35 shots, keeping his floundering team close into the third period. Zach Werenski, who won the Norris Trophy last season as the NHL’s top defenseman, skated around defenseman Ryan Pulock and slipped in a backhander at the crease to cut the Islanders’ lead to 2-1 at 1:12 of the third.
But Schaefer regained a two-goal edge with his second goal, backhanding in a rebound at 7:01 of the third period. Blue Jackets interim coach Don Granato, behind the bench while Rick Bowness recovers from a medical issue, unsuccessfully challenged Casey Cizikas had interfered with Talbot.
His unassisted goal from the high slot at 1:34 of the second period put the Islanders ahead 2-0 and defenseman Tony DeAngelo made it 4-1 at 11:52 of the third period.
Schaefer completed his hat trick at 16:08 of the third period.
Mathew Barzal, playing in his first home game after missing all of training camp and the season’s first 18 games with a left knee injury, had the primary assists on both DeAngelo’s tally and Anthony Duclair’s power-play goal with 57.3 seconds left in the first period that opened the scoring.
It gave the Islanders’ power-play goals in four straight games for the second time this season.
The Islanders played without third-line center Jean-Gabriel Pageau and defenseman Logan Stanley, both out with lower-body injuries.
More Islanders





